In a word: addictive. Made with mayo, paprika, and sharp white cheddar, Parmesan, Gruyère, and pecorino cheeses, Star Provisions' homemade pimento cheese is served in rustic little Mason jars at the cheese counter. Each dollop is creamy, chunky, chewy, and strikingly sharp. Make sure you have plenty of crusty bread on hand, one bite is never enough. $10 per pound.